How to Nurture New Email Subscribers Effectively

Discover a proven post-growth strategy to boost trust and engagement from day one.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

How to personalize emails for better engagement?

Personalizing your emails can significantly increase engagement and build stronger relationships with your subscribers.

"Make sure that every new subscriber gets a personal welcome email. Share something behind the scenes, invite them to tell you where they're at. Start the conversation."

Takeaway:
  • Use subscribers' first names to personalize your emails.
  • Include behind-the-scenes content to build connection.
  • Encourage replies to turn emails into conversations.

Why engage subscribers immediately after growth?

Immediate engagement after a surge in subscribers ensures that new audience members remain interested and connected.

"It's not a launch issue, it's a relationship issue. You wouldn't meet someone once, ghost them for months, and then ask them to invest in your signature offer."

Takeaway:
  • Engage with new subscribers promptly to build relationships.
  • Maintain consistent communication to nurture trust.
  • Avoid long periods of silence that can weaken the connection.

How to create engaging content simply?

Generating engaging email content doesn't have to be complex; simplicity can be highly effective.

"The bottom line is nurture doesn't have to mean 52 weeks of mapped content, but it does mean showing up. It means being in their inbox when you're not selling."

Takeaway:
  • Focus on consistent, authentic communications over elaborate campaigns.
  • Share stories, insights, and value to keep subscribers interested.
  • Simplicity and authenticity can outperform overcomplicated strategies.

How to re-engage a dormant email list?

If you've fallen out of touch with your email list, there are ways to reignite the relationship and get them engaged again.

"There’s a whole module in there about relationship-based nurture, including how to write re-engagement emails, how to repurpose content from your podcast or blog, and how to use simple frameworks that save you time."

Takeaway:
  • Utilize re-engagement emails to reconnect with inactive subscribers.
  • Share valuable content to remind them why they joined your list.
  • Encourage interaction to rebuild trust and interest.

Why write emails to one person?

Crafting your emails as if you're speaking to one person can make your messages more personal and impactful.

"Don't write to your audience. Write to her. That one woman who's thinking about giving up, that one woman who's craving some clarity, that one woman who needs to feel seen and not sold to."

Takeaway:
  • Personalize your messaging to resonate deeply with individual subscribers.
  • Focus on addressing specific pain points and needs.
  • Create a stronger connection by making each subscriber feel seen and understood.

How to turn subscribers into super fans?

Converting subscribers into enthusiastic supporters requires consistent nurturing and genuine relationship-building.

"Start nurturing the ones you already have. Your people are waiting to hear from you. Please, for the love of Taylor Swift, do not keep them waiting."

Takeaway:
  • Treat subscribers as individuals, not just numbers.
  • Show up consistently with valuable and authentic content.
  • Build trust by engaging with your audience on a personal level.

How to make a great first impression?

Making a strong first impression with new subscribers is essential for building a lasting relationship and encouraging engagement.

"Having something to welcome people in, set expectations, and start that relationship off on the right foot is key."

Takeaway:
  • Send a personalized welcome email immediately after they subscribe.
  • Reference where they came from to make them feel seen.
  • Provide valuable content and invite them to start a conversation.

Why prioritize nurturing over list growth?

Focusing on nurturing your current subscribers can have a greater impact on conversions than constantly seeking new ones.

"Not all email lists convert, even when they're growing. And I wanted to call that out with love, but also with honesty. It is not your open rate. It is not your magnet and no, it's not the size of your list either. The real problem I see far too often is that you haven't nurtured the relationship."

Takeaway:
  • Build relationships with existing subscribers instead of only chasing new ones.
  • Engage your audience regularly to maintain their interest and trust.
  • Effective nurturing leads to higher conversion rates from your current list.

Should you use a 'Start Here' email or a welcome sequence?

Deciding between sending a detailed welcome sequence or a single 'Start Here' email can impact how effectively you engage new subscribers.

"I had a 'start here' email instead of a full welcome sequence. Now, I know you've heard me talk about welcome sequences before, and honestly, they do still have their place, but right now, I'm testing something new, a single start here email that gives my new subscribers everything they need to hit the ground running."

Takeaway:
  • Consider a single 'Start Here' email to quickly engage new subscribers.
  • Provide curated resources and personal insights to build connection.
  • Invite subscribers to reply to encourage engagement and conversation.

How to nurture new email subscribers effectively?

Nurturing new email subscribers is crucial to building trust and converting them into loyal customers.

"Because trust has a shelf life and if you're not showing up soon after somebody joins your world, the connection goes cold and so do your sales."

Takeaway:
  • Reach out to new subscribers promptly to build and maintain trust.
  • Avoid ghosting your new subscribers after they join your list.
  • Implement a nurturing strategy immediately to keep your audience engaged.

Episode Info:

Title:
How I Personally Nurture New Subscribers & How You Can Too! [Ep 203]
Episode Link:
Keywords:
email marketing, list nurturing, audience engagement
Episode Air Date:
June 27, 2025

Podcast info:

Show Name:
The Email Growth Show
Author:
Kylie Kelly
Owner:
Kylie Kelly
Category:
Marketing

More summaries from this podcast:

Stop Pretending Content Is Valuable

-
Why authenticity matters over imitation
-
How to shift from noise to meaningful content
-
Why your audience needs clarity, not more content
-
How to create content that moves people
-
How authenticity boosts engagement
View summary

EFT Tapping: Recharge Goals with Jacqui Acree

-
Why acknowledge emotions in marketing?
-
How to use tapping to enhance marketing?
-
Why embrace the cyclical nature of marketing?
-
How to set realistic marketing expectations?
-
Is perfectionism blocking your marketing success?
View summary